Quick answer
It depends on what is inside. PDFs full of photos became 65% smaller on the default level (118 MB → 41 MB) and up to 92% on the strongest. Papers with charts shrank 11–35%. Text-only PDFs did not shrink at all, and library scans hardly — their pages were already stored efficiently. When a PDF cannot get smaller, the tool keeps the original.
How we tested
- 15 public PDFs in four groups, 2 to 543 pages each:
- 4 photo-heavy research papers about image generation (12–46 pages, 11–43 MB) from arXiv;
- 3 papers with charts and diagrams (12–75 pages) from arXiv;
- 4 scanned books in the public domain from the Internet Archive (16–543 pages);
- 4 text documents: US tax forms and instructions from irs.gov (2–142 pages).
- Tool: our Compress PDF, the same code as on the site, run in Chrome on a 2019 laptop (Intel Core i7-8665U). Each file at Light, Recommended, Strong and Extreme.
- Measured: size before and after, and the time from dropping the file to the download being ready.
The results per group
| Group (total size) | Light | Recommended | Strong | Extreme |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Photo-heavy papers (118 MB) | −37% | −65% | −77% | −86% |
| Papers with charts (9.8 MB) | −11% | −25% | −35% | −4% |
| Scanned books (35 MB) | −1% | −1% | −1% | −11% |
| Text documents (8 MB) | 0% | 0% | 0% | 0% |
The single best result: a 43 MB, 27-page paper full of generated images went to 11.6 MB on Recommended and 3.4 MB on Extreme. The smallest gain on a photo-heavy file was still 43% on Recommended.
Why some PDFs don't shrink
- Text is already small. The four tax documents — up to 142 pages — are mostly text and vector lines. There is nothing to recompress, so the tool returned the originals unchanged rather than a "compressed" copy of the same size.
- Library scans are already compressed. The Internet Archive stores scanned pages in JPEG 2000, a format made for exactly this. Light, Recommended and Strong leave those images alone (−1%). Only Extreme, which redraws every page, helped on two of the four books (−41% and −48%); on the other two the result would have been larger, so the original was kept.
- Charts are not photos. Diagrams and plots are often vector graphics. On the chart papers Extreme even did worse than Strong, because turning crisp vector pages into images costs more bytes than it saves.
How long it takes
- Light to Strong: under a second for small files, 6–10 seconds for the 40 MB papers, 13 seconds for the 142-page tax guide.
- Extreme redraws every page, so time grows with the page count: 2–5 seconds for the photo papers, but 31 seconds for a 16-page scan and almost two minutes for the 256-page book.
On a phone it takes a little longer: a 25 MB PDF took 1.5 s on a Galaxy S25 Ultra against 1.0 s on the laptop.
What we fixed because of this test
The first run showed the scanned books shrinking by 84–97% on Extreme — suspiciously much. Opening the result showed why: every page was blank. The PDF engine in the browser could not load its JPEG 2000 decoder, so it drew the scanned pages as white. We fixed that the same day (28 October 2026) by shipping the decoders with the site; the numbers above are from the run after the fix. The same fix applies to PDF to JPG, which uses the same engine. If you used Extreme or PDF to JPG on a scanned PDF before that date and got empty pages, please try again.
Which level to choose
- Recommended for nearly everything — the biggest step in size for photos, with text and charts untouched.
- Strong when a portal has a hard limit; photos get softer, fine on screen.
- Extreme only for photo-heavy PDFs when size matters most: the text can no longer be selected or searched.
- Still too big? Split it with Split PDF. Background on what makes PDFs heavy: Why is my PDF so big?
Limits of this test
- 15 files is a small sample, and research papers are not the same as, say, a photo book or a scanned invoice from your phone.
- Phone scans saved as ordinary JPEG behave like the photo group, not like the library scans.
- We measured size, not how good each result looks; Strong and Extreme visibly soften photos.
Frequently asked questions
How much can you compress a PDF?
It depends almost entirely on the photos inside. In our test, PDFs full of photos became 65% smaller on the default level and up to 92% on the strongest; text-only PDFs could not be made smaller at all.
Why did compressing my PDF not make it smaller?
Either it contains hardly any images, or its images are already stored efficiently, as in many library scans. A good tool then keeps the original instead of making it worse.
Which compression level should I use?
Recommended for almost everything. Use Strong for strict upload limits, and Extreme only when size matters more than being able to select and search the text.